No Man’s Sky Review: Part Two – The Verdict

no man's sky

No Man’s Sky (PS4, PC)
Developer: Hello Games
Release: August 9, 2016
Price: $50/R900
Score: 9 out of 10 

I’ve spent 40 hours with No Man’s Sky and in that time I’ve thoroughly explored the cosmos, blasting my way between solar systems and diving down deep into planets galore. I’ve bought starships, pillaged minerals, traded with alien explorers and splashed the cash. Life in the stars is much like life on earth. Make money, buy stuff and take pictures along the way. It’s in many ways an aimless trek, and after all this time, I still haven’t reached the centre of the universe, the game’s designated end game. And you know what? That doesn’t bother me.

no man's sky
Spotted a planet found by EdwardloveZA? Let me know in the comments below!

Normally I don’t write a review until I’ve finished the game in question, but I realize now that the joy of No Man’s Sky is in the journey, not the destination. So long as you’re not rushing to try and see the credits roll, anyone can pick up this title, feed it into their console and walk away impressed.

Read: No Man’s Sky Review: Part One – Impressions

Not everyone agrees. Two weeks since its release the dust is settling, the hype has vanished and hyperbole of a different kind is emanating from all four corners of the net. We’re left with a product naked for the world to see, and while some of you love it, just as many of you are crying foul play.

One thing no one can deny is No Man Sky’s beauty.

no man's sky
You’ll find yourself pausing to take screenshots constantly.

Just take a look at some of the screenshots dotted throughout this review. Planets teem with life, light, colour and discovering a tropical planet rich in fauna and flora is a joy. It’s beautiful in a way I’ve never experienced before, and these colourful planets you’ll no doubt gravitate towards, leaving a barren rock as soon as it materializes. But sometimes, disembarking on a dry slab of land gives you something better – a surprise. Explore, and you’ll come across ultra rare minerals and once-off discoveries. You never know what you’ll find – and that’s a key ingredient in the exlir.

Individual maps are enormous and could take an entire day to explore. That there are more than a quantillion to discover, all procedurally generated, boggles the mind. Even so, I have already come across two slabs of rock that have been discovered by other players – and may well find more.

no man's sky
Look at that colour!

That raises a question: is this a shared universe or not? Recent controversy suggest it isn’t, but that shouldn’t put you off. This is a solitary journey in every sense, punctuated by brief encounters with aliens who sell you minerals and buy your trinkets. Trade turns out to be a big complement of the experience, but these sentient encounters are driven by text and eerily devoid of audio. These traders are your friend because you can’t just hop into your ship and explore. Your ship needs fuel, and for that, you need materials. Mining valuable resources can net you big bucks and the first time you discover a rock of gold the size of a double-storey house, you’ll rejoice.

no man's sky
Not all of the animals in the game look – well, fully formed. I’d rather not say what this one looks like!

But mining isn’t always fun. The acquisition of materials is a form of manual labour and one that’s necessary to progress in the game. Both your ship and your suit only have space for a limited amount of space rock, which means you’ll either need to upgrade your carrying capacity or make return trips to grab the stuff you need. This can get wearisome, but there’s a watershed moment when you realize that you can solve the problem by simply being clear about where you want to go and what you want to build. A huge amount of criticism has been lobbed at inventory management in the game, and rightly so, but it forces you to find solutions without having your hand held.

Inventory quibbles aside, I think No Man’s Sky is the victim of the modern review cycle, which necessitates we burn the midnight oil to deliver a verdict on time. With copies landing on press desks at the eleventh hour, reviewers have been pressed harder than ever to squeeze every last drop of energy out of the game. That’s not the way to best enjoy No Man’s Sky, which doesn’t lend itself to marathon sessions, but is better enjoyed like a sugary drink you dip into at odd hours of the day; sip, smack your teeth and re-cork.

Take it slow and you’ll resist the urge to simply build warp drives and head straight for the center of the universe, which would rob you of No Man’s Sky’s secondary delights, like finding diagrams for better gear, or coming across highly precious resources at random, or learning new alien languages, or stumbling across a side story dubbed Atlas. The Atlas storyline is, I believe, a late addition to the package and one hurriedly dashed off to add narrative structure to the game, and while it’s not perfect, it’s a neat incentive to keep you going as you rack up the voyager miles.

no man's sky
Blue grass. I want it.

If you go into No Man’s Sky in search of meaning, purpose, direction, you’ll walk away disappointed. And frankly, that’s foolish. No Man’s Sky can be as aimless as space itself, letting you do as you please with only ever a subtle nudge in the right direction. This isn’t a role-playing game with experience points and skill trees. It’s what you make of it.

All the gamey stuff necessarily protracts what we’re really after: the joy of hopping into a space craft and discovering some new delights for our eyes and ears. And make no mistake – there’s plenty. Though the allure will eventually wear off (and how could it not?), there’s 40+ hours of content to enjoy before you reach a plateau.

no man's sky
Spectacular moon vistas are common.

Most games are judged in an objective light: a tick for a plus point, a minus for a niggle. No Man’s Sky is more subjective. The world you will see will be different from the one I’ve seen and all I can say is this: If you’ve ever been fascinated by the idea of space exploration No Man’s Sky will make you draw breath. I’ve never played a game where I’ve taken so many screenshots, or been so willing to show off to friends. Take your time with it and you’ll learn to love a game that, through its stunning beauty, is more than the sum of its parts and stuffed with surprises that make you smile. You’ll take delight in the journey: the magic of maths, science and art working together in beautiful union.

I’ve absolutely loved it.

Discovered a planet that I colonized first (EdwardLoveZA)? Drop me a comment in the thread below! 

no man's sky


In this article

Join the Conversation